Why ‘Made in Italy’ is often a lie

April 1, 2016

What do we buy when we buy “Made In Italy?” Every time I visit a factory-whether it is in Italy or China-I’m amazed by the whole production process. To me, it’s beautiful-from the mixing of block acetate to form sheets, through the cutting of frame fronts and temples, shooting the temple core, tumbling, and finally, assembly.

The views expressed here belong to the author. They do not necessarily represent the views of Optometry Times or UBM Medica.

What do we buy when we buy “Made In Italy?” Every time I visit a factory-whether it is in Italy or China-I’m amazed by the whole production process. To me, it’s beautiful-from the mixing of block acetate to form sheets, through the cutting of frame fronts and temples, shooting the temple core, tumbling, and finally, assembly.

And they’re not that different.

I’ve seen bad eyewear come from Italy and great eyewear come from China. So, what am I really buying when I buy handmade Italian eyewear? To me it’s much of the experience I’ve had when visiting those Italian factories. It’s about being a part of a long history of innovation and culture that takes its time to do things right.

More blogs: Why it's OK to be bossy

Sometimes fronts and temples are made in China and stamped “Made in Italy.” That statement alone is shocking to me, and although I’ve heard it mentioned before, it didn’t have the impact on me until I witnessed it. I’m not talking small brands either; I’m talking major international brands that we all know, talk about, and many of you might be selling to your customers every day.

It’s not illegal

According to Italian law, there are no limits on how much of a product must be made in country to earn the mark.1 So, large companies manufacture everything in China, then ship it to Italy for the final assembly. In essence, the Italians place the final screws in each hinge or grind the lenses and install them, and by Italian law, that’s enough.2

It’s legal, so it’s OK, right? Well, herein lies the moral dilemma. We all know the premium we pay for Italian products, we all know what the name means. It means quality, trust, and craftsmanship. We’re paying more knowing their origin. It’s a bait-and-switch tactic, using cheap Chinese labor and the allure of Italian manufacturing,3 and the worst part is we have no idea how many brands/companies are doing it.

More blogs: 3 tips to use LinkedIn to advance your career

It’s especially frustrating to me because I follow the craft of Italian eyewear manufacturing. I pay a premium to sleep at night, and our frames sit alongside those with morals weaker than our own. And, unfortunately there’s no way to tell the difference to the average wholesale buyer, distributor, or customer. Hell, it’s even hard for us to tell sometimes.

Next: If I can't tell, it's OK?

 

If I can’t tell, it’s OK?

If I can buy quality anywhere, it means I’m buying more than that when I buy Italian. So when I make a purchase to support an idea, and instead I’ve been lied to, it makes the switch all the worse.

You and your patients are paying a premium. The brands/companies are the ones benefiting on their distrust, and I don’t think it’s a path we or Italy should allow any longer.

More from Konrad: 7 Beatles songs for improving office culture

As I mentioned in my last post, transparency is essential in our industry progressing and moving forward. We need to build customer trust more than ever, and this deceitful manufacturing is a starting point. It can start with the companies (highly unlikely), or it can start with us. We should demand transparency from the people we buy from, ask the hard questions, and understand what we are (and aren’t) paying for.

Click here to check out more Optometry Times blogs

 

References

1. Rock Center with Brian Williams. Presto! Designer products made by Chinese get ‘Made in Italy’ stamp. 2012 Oct 12. Available at: http://rockcenter.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/10/12/14392020-presto-designer-products-made-by-chinese-get-made-in-italy-stamp. Accessed 03/31/2016.

2. Bonior J. Seeing through the lens: American-made eyewear. Alliance for American Manufacturing. 2015 Aug 12. Available at:  http://www.americanmanufacturing.org/blog/entry/seeing-through-the-lens-american-made-eyewear. Accessed 03/31/2016.

3. Thomas D. Made in China on the Sky. New York Times. 2007 Nov 23. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/23/opinion/23thomas.html. Accessed 03/31/2016.